THE LEAD
A 2021 992 Carrera sold on BaT for $88,000 on February 18th. The average 992 on BaT over the last eight months? $278,601.
That's 68% below average. For a three-year-old car.
I went through every Porsche sale in January and February looking for cars that sold significantly below their generation average. Not junk. Not salvage titles. Real cars that — for one reason or another — went for far less than the market typically demands.
Some of these are genuine opportunities. Others are traps. Knowing the difference is the whole game.
AUCTION INTEL
The 5 Biggest Discounts (vs. Generation Average)
Year | Model | Gen | Price | Gen Avg | Discount | Why |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
2021 | 911 Carrera | 992 | $88,000 | $279K | -68% | Base Carrera, 22K miles. No S, no sport exhaust, PDK. |
2011 | 911 Carrera Cab | 997.2 | $38,250 | $128K | -70% | Cabriolet penalty + likely high miles |
2009 | 997.2 Carrera S | 997.2 | $40,250 | $128K | -69% | 136K miles, modified, no reserve |
1992 | 911 Carrera 2 Cab | 964 | $65,964 | $198K | -67% | Cabriolet in a coupe-driven market |
2011 | 911 Carrera 4S Cab | 997.2 | $44,000 | $128K | -66% | Another cab. See the pattern? |
The pattern screams at you: cabriolets are the discount aisle of the Porsche market. Four of the five biggest discounts are drop-tops. If you want to drive a Porsche — not park it, not flip it, actually drive it — the cabriolet tax is working in your favor right now.
MARKET PULSE
Generation averages (last 8 months, BaT only):
992: $279K avg (202 sales) — GT3s and GT3 RSs pull this way up. Base Carreras trade $80K-$130K.
993: $234K avg (102 sales) — Turbos dominate the top. Non-Turbo coupes: $100K-$160K.
991.2: $200K avg (115 sales) — GT3s and GT2 RS skew high. Standard Carreras: $65K-$90K.
997.2: $128K avg (94 sales) — GT3/GT3 RS inflate this. Carrera S coupes: $55K-$75K.
997.1: $73K avg (169 sales) — most accessible 911 generation. Clean Carrera S under $50K.
996: $42K avg (230 sales) — Turbos at $60K-$100K. Base cars from $15K-$35K.
THE DEEP CUT
The Cabriolet Discount Is Real — And Maybe Irrational
Here's a thesis I've been sitting on: the market undervalues Porsche cabriolets by 25-40% versus their coupe equivalents, and for most buyers, that discount doesn't make sense.
Look at the data. That 2011 997.2 Carrera at $38,250? The last 997.2 Carrera coupe with similar specs sold for $62,000. That's a 38% discount for a folding roof.
The common arguments against cabriolets — structural rigidity, weight, looks — are real for track cars. But 95% of 911 owners never see a track. They drive PCH on weekends. They take them to PCA meets. They park at Cars & Coffee.
For those people, a cabriolet is strictly better. And right now, the market is pricing them like they're broken.
The exceptions: Don't apply this logic to GT cars. A GT3 Touring holds value because it's rare and track-focused. A Carrera cabriolet is cheap because it's common and lifestyle-focused. Different animals.
The opportunity: If you're looking for the most car for the money and you genuinely plan to keep it for 3-5 years, buy the cabriolet. A 997.2 Carrera S cab with 50K-70K miles for $40K-$50K is one of the best deals in the market right now. The depreciation curve is nearly flat at that level — you won't lose money, and you'll enjoy the car more.
If you're buying: Check the convertible top motor and hydraulics ($2K-$4K repair if failed). Inspect the rear window for delamination. And budget for a set of good all-seasons — if you're saving $20K on the car, you can afford to drive it year-round.
PIT LANE
Auctions ending this week: A 2015 991.1 Carrera GTS cab in Sapphire Blue (BaT — this is the sweet spot of usability + value), a 2007 997.1 Carrera S coupe 6-speed under $50K (BaT), and a 981 Cayman GTS that's been creeping up all week (PCarMarket)
Hot take: The 992 Carrera (non-S, non-GTS) is going to be the most undervalued 911 of the 2020s. Base 992s are fantastic cars trading for a third of their generation average. In 5 years, people will wish they bought at $90K.
Tool of the week: Hagerty Valuation Tools — I know, I give Hagerty grief for their accuracy. But their free tool is useful as a starting point, especially for insurance quotes. Just don't treat their "Excellent" condition value as gospel. Real auction data (like what you're reading right now) is the only reliable price source.
RennPulse — Porsche market intelligence, every Tuesday.
5 River Road, Suite 119, Wilton, CT 06897